We asked AI who to hire 1,488 times
Between 13 October and 2 November 2026 we asked ChatGPT and Perplexity who to hire in 31 local markets across the United States. Plumbers, roofers, electricians, air conditioning, house cleaning, painting, a florist, a photographer and a med spa.
In each market we asked the eight questions a customer would type, three times each, on each tool. That is 48 answers a market and 1,488 in all. Every answer named at least one business and listed the pages it used. We counted both.
The two tools read different pages
Perplexity listed about 10 pages per answer. ChatGPT listed about 3. The kind of page was different too.
Perplexity did not cite a government page once in 744 answers. ChatGPT cited one in almost one answer in five. If you only check one tool, you only see half of what goes into the answer.
Most businesses were named by only one tool
Across the 31 markets, 1,101 businesses were named at least once. 300 of them, about 27%, were named by both ChatGPT and Perplexity. The rest came up on one tool only.
So a good result on ChatGPT tells you little about Perplexity, and the other way round.
Being named often is rare
The typical market had 34 different businesses named across its 48 answers. The most named business in a market came up in a median of 17. Only 8 businesses in all 31 markets were named in half of their market's answers or more. About 3 in 10 of the businesses named came up exactly once.
What we would do with this
- Look yourself up on your state's license lookup and check the name matches your website. ChatGPT reads those pages.
- Check the directories and review sites that come up when you search your trade and your city. Perplexity read them in three answers out of four.
- Say your trade, your city and your services in plain words on your own site. Local businesses' own sites were cited in about nine answers out of ten.
- Measure each tool on its own. They disagree too often to treat as one.
How we counted, and what it cannot tell you
We sorted every cited site into a type by hand: directory or review site, national chain, government, manufacturer, news, or other. Nearly all of the other sites are local businesses' own websites. Names were matched after removing punctuation and words like LLC and Inc, so a few businesses may still be counted twice.
This shows what the tools read, not why they chose a name. It covers three weeks in autumn 2026, and answers change from one ask to the next. Treat it as a map of where to look, not a forecast of what happens when you fix something.